Army Chief Confirms US Will Hand off ISIS Fight in Syria

By Kevin Baron and Patrick Tucker

January 16, 2019

For the first time, a senior U.S. military official has commented on President Trump’s late-December decision to quit Syria, confirming publicly that American troops are planning to leave once ISIS is defeated on the ground.

We are determined to finish that off and then hand the battle off to our indigenous partners,” Army Chief of Staff Gen. Mark Milley said on Wednesday.

His comments came hours after a suicide bomber killed four people in Manbij, Syria, including two U.S. troops, a Defense Department civilian, and one contractor. Three more were injured in the blast, for which ISIS declared responsibility.

Milley did not say when U.S. troops would leave Syria, but his characterization suggests a change of one mission goal for the Americans, who until Trump's tweet last December were intending to remain in country until UN-brokered talks reached a peace deal in Geneva. The Trump administration had hoped to negotiate with Russia, Turkey, Iran, Syria’s Bashar al-Assad, and other NATO partners. The Army chief's comment also suggests that mission would not include National Security Advisor John Bolton’s pledge, made last autumn, to keep U.S. troops in Syria as long as Iranian-backed foot soldiers remain there.

Until now, no four-star U.S. military leader has commented publicly on any aspect of Trump’s Syria plans, as administration officials have struggled to interpret and carry out the president’s oft-changing orders.

On Dec. 19, Trump declared ISIS defeated; shortly thereafter, he called for an immediate and total withdrawal of U.S. forces from Syria within 30 days. Their presence, would be replaced by Turkish troops, he said. But in subsequent weeks, following criticism from Capitol Hill to allied capitals, Trump and other administration officials have softened their stance. They now say the U.S. will not immediately withdraw all troops, as there was more fighting to be done, and because Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan rejected Trump’s demands that they protect Kurds, whom Turkey sees in part as terrorists and separatists.

Currently, U.S. forces are fighting “a relatively small amount of remnants of ISIS — Daesh — as an organization, bottled up in a very small geographical area,” Milley told the Association of the U.S. Army audience just outside Washington, D.C.

Milley said the United States. is determined to hand the fight off to “indigenous partners” — by which he seemed to mean he U.S.-led Syrian Democratic Forces, and not Turkey.

But a spokesman for the general later clarified that Milley had meant the 74-nation counter-ISIS coalition, which includes Turkey.

The general’s imprecise language underscores the difficulty of interpreting — and publicly discussing — the wishes of Trump and his administration. Among the outstanding questions: how to determine when the ground fight against ISIS is done; how the U.S. military will hand off security responsibilities for one-third of Syria; and just who will pick those responsibilities up.

Of late, the Trump administration’s Syria strategy has been marked by reversals and confusion, with the Pentagon, White House, and State Department seemingly unable to get on the same page. Milley said that appearance of confusion and lack of coordination between executive-branch agencies — and allies — was in fact normal.

Look, American foreign policy, American national security policy, for decades, not just now, is a combination of puts and takes between various branches of our government. It is a process. Some people from the outside look at it and think it’s chaotic, think there is no process. Others from the inside think it’s chaotic and there is no process. That’s been true, those criticisms have been true since it began a couple hundred years ago, right? I don’t see anything particularly novel about these criticisms.”

Wednesday’s bombing comes days after Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s Middle East tour sought to convince allies the United States would remain engaged in the region, and prompted assurances from the White House that plan would hold true.

Vice President Mike Pence condemned the bombing, saying in a statement, “Thanks to the courage of our Armed Forces, we have crushed the ISIS caliphate and devastated its capabilities. As we begin to bring our troops home, the American people can be assured, for the sake of our soldiers, their families, and our nation, we will never allow the remnants of ISIS to reestablish their evil and murderous caliphate – not now, not ever.”

At the Pentagon, Acting Defense Secretary Patrick Shanahan said, "Our fight against terrorism is ongoing and we will remain vigilant and committed to its destruction. Today is a stark reminder of the dangerous missions that men and women in uniform perform on our behalf each and every day." He spoke not at a press conference — Shanahan has not given one in his new capacity — but during a short ceremony to welcome Japanese Defense Minister Takeshi Iwaya to the Pentagon.

When Shanahan was asked whether the bombing would affect Syria withdrawal, he replied, “What I'd normally say is we could take a few questions, but today our agenda is so packed that I wouldn't want to shortchange our guests, but I look forward to talking to you in the future. Thank you."

Katie Bo Williams contributed to this report.


By Kevin Baron and Patrick Tucker // Kevin Baron is the founding executive editor of Defense One. Baron has lived in Washington for 20 years, covering international affairs, the military, the Pentagon, Congress, and politics for Foreign Policy, National Journal, Stars and Stripes, and the Boston Globe, where he ran investigative projects for five years at the Washington bureau. He is a frequent on-air contributor and previously was national security/military analyst at NBC News & MSNBC. Baron cut his muckraking teeth at the Center for Public Integrity and he is twice a Polk Award winner and former vice president of the Pentagon Press Association. He earned his M.A. in media and public affairs from George Washington University, his B.A. in international studies from the University of Richmond, and studied in Paris. Raised in Florida, Baron now lives in Northern Virginia. // Patrick Tucker is technology editor for Defense One. He’s also the author of The Naked Future: What Happens in a World That Anticipates Your Every Move? (Current, 2014). Previously, Tucker was deputy editor for The Futurist for nine years. Tucker has written about emerging technology in Slate, The Sun, MIT Technology Review, Wilson Quarterly, The American Legion Magazine, BBC News Magazine, Utne Reader, and elsewhere.

January 16, 2019

https://www.defenseone.com/news/2019/01/army-chief-confirms-us-will-hand-isis-fight-syria/154237/